Most Offers in Compromise fail for predictable reasons: the offer is returned because returns are unfiled, estimated payments are missing or the fee was not paid, or it is rejected because the amount is below the IRS’s reasonable collection potential. Other causes are unexplained bank deposits, undervalued assets, expenses above IRS standards without proof, and not answering document requests by the deadline.
Key facts
- Returned vs. rejected
- Returned = not processable (no appeal); rejected = reviewed and declined (appeal rights)
- Most common rejection cause
- Offer amount below reasonable collection potential
- Appeal deadline
- Generally 30 days from the rejection letter
- Payments with the offer
- Generally kept by the IRS and applied to your balance
- Levy protection
- Continues for 30 days after rejection and during a timely appeal
Returned offers: rejected before anyone looks at the numbers
A returned offer was never evaluated. The IRS sends it back because a basic requirement was not met, and a return generally cannot be appealed. Common causes:
- Unfiled tax returns. Every required return must be filed.
- Missing estimated payments for the current year, or missing payroll tax deposits for businesses.
- No application fee or initial payment, without qualifying for the low-income waiver.
- Open bankruptcy.
- Incomplete forms, such as an unsigned Form 656 or a missing Form 433-A (OIC).
- Not filing a return or paying a new tax while the offer is pending.
Check the Offer in Compromise eligibility checklist before filing.
Rejected offers: the numbers do not support the amount
Once an Offer Examiner reviews your file, the main question is whether your offer equals or exceeds your reasonable collection potential (RCP). The most frequent problems:
1. Assets valued too low
Home equity, retirement accounts and vehicles are often valued lower on the application than the IRS will value them. The examiner uses quick-sale value, typically 80% of fair market value, and checks public records and statements.
2. Expenses above IRS standards
Your actual rent, car payment or other costs may be higher than the Collection Financial Standards allow. Without proof that the higher cost is necessary, the examiner substitutes the standard, which raises your future income and your RCP.
3. Income that does not match the bank statements
Examiners compare deposits with stated income. Unexplained deposits, cash income, or transfers from family members raise questions and can increase the income figure.
4. Dissipated assets
If you sold or spent assets after the tax was owed, on things that were not necessary living expenses, the IRS can add their value back into your RCP.
5. Not responding on time
Examiners send document requests with deadlines. Missing one can lead to the offer being closed.
The full calculation is explained in how the IRS evaluates an Offer in Compromise.
Other reasons an offer can be rejected
- Public policy. The IRS can reject an offer if accepting it would be against public policy, for example in some criminal cases.
- You can pay in full. If your RCP exceeds the balance, the IRS will expect an installment agreement or full payment instead.
- Effective Tax Administration offers without strong facts. These require exceptional circumstances and are accepted far less often than collectibility offers.
What to do if your offer is rejected
- Read the rejection letter and the examiner’s RCP calculation. Request the income/expense and asset workpapers if they were not included.
- Find where the numbers differ from yours: asset values, allowed expenses, income averaging.
- Appeal within the deadline, generally 30 days, using Form 13711 or the instructions in your letter. The IRS Independent Office of Appeals reviews the case separately from the examiner.
- Or choose a different path. If the examiner’s numbers are right, an installment agreement, partial-pay agreement or Currently Not Collectible status may be the better outcome.
Payments you made with the offer generally stay with the IRS and are applied to your balance. Levy protection continues for 30 days after the rejection and while a timely appeal is pending.
How to build an offer that holds up
- Get fully compliant first, and stay compliant during the review.
- Calculate the RCP the way the examiner will, using IRS standards and quick-sale values.
- Attach documentation for every asset value and every expense that exceeds the standards.
- Explain irregular income and unusual deposits before the examiner asks.
- Answer every document request completely and early.
From inside the IRS
I spent seven years as an IRS Appeals Officer. Many rejected offers that reached Appeals were close; the disagreement was over one or two items, like a vehicle value or how self-employment income was averaged. Appeals can weigh the evidence and the hazards differently than an examiner. Knowing which items are worth contesting is what makes an appeal productive.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a returned and a rejected Offer in Compromise?
A returned offer was not processed because a requirement was missing, such as unfiled returns or an unpaid fee, and generally cannot be appealed. A rejected offer was evaluated and declined, and you generally have 30 days to appeal.
Do I get my money back if my Offer in Compromise is rejected?
Generally no. The application fee and payments sent with the offer are kept and applied to your tax balance, unless you qualified for the low-income waiver.
Can I resubmit an Offer in Compromise after it is rejected?
Yes. You can submit a new offer, ideally after fixing what caused the rejection. If your finances have changed, a new offer may reflect a different reasonable collection potential. An appeal is often the better first step.
How do I appeal a rejected Offer in Compromise?
Follow the instructions in the rejection letter, usually by filing Form 13711, Request for Appeal of Offer in Compromise, within 30 days of the letter date.
Will the IRS levy me after my offer is rejected?
The IRS generally cannot levy for 30 days after a rejection and while a timely appeal is pending. After that, collection can resume unless another arrangement is in place.
Talk to a former IRS insider, free
Every IRS case turns on the details. Israel will review your notices and finances and tell you honestly which option fits, at no cost and with no obligation.
Call (201) 829-3569Book a free consultationRelated reading
Sources
- IRS: Offer in Compromise
- IRS Form 656 Booklet
- IRS: About Form 13711 (appeal of OIC)
- Internal Revenue Manual 5.8.7: Rejection, Return and Withdrawal
Published 2026-11-03. This article is general information, not legal or tax advice for your situation. IRS rules, thresholds and fees change; check IRS.gov or talk to a professional before acting.
